World heritage encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most. The time has come, it seems, to erect a new tombstone for thomas jefferson. Sally hemings, thomas jefferson and the ways we talk about our. Brodie offers an intimate history, chronologically pursued. I was looking for a narrative history of the relationship of thomas jefferson and sally hemings, his slave who now we know genetically bore him several children. The portrait that results adds a whole new depth to. In her early teens, gordonreed learned of the hemings family from, among other sources, fawn brodie s 1974 biography thomas jefferson. She said brodie had included recollections dating from 1873 of two men, madison hemings and israel jefferson gillette. Jefferson wrote to madison in code that they should pray for. Jeffersons daughters three sisters, white and black, in a young america by catherine kerrison illustrated. Voyeurs will skip the parts about jeffersons political life and his relations with adams, hamilton and burr. United states and one of his slaves, sally hemings, which she.
Jeffersons liaison with sally hemings lasted thirtyeight years and resulted in seven children, two of whom died in infancy. The necessity for secrecy concerning jeffersons liaison with sally hemings pervaded. But i read gordonreeds book, for a different reason to shed any light on the chance that jefferson had murdered his wife martha to be with sally. A seminal biography of thomas jefferson and a fascinating exploration of his relationship with sally hemings. Brodie portrays thomas jefferson as he wrestled with great issues of his time. Brodies reinterpretation of jeffersons inner life, the most important new piece of evidence advanced in support of jeffersons fathering sally hemingss children is an 1873 newspaper interview with sallys son madison. This item is available to borrow from 1 library branch. Id read fawn brodie s book on jefferson back in 1975 when i was 18. Brodie was interviewed on nbcs today show, and the book quickly became a topic of.
In the book, brodie focused on jeffersons private life, and was one of the first to strongly argue that there was a relationship between the president and his slave, sally hemings. Renowned historian recounts jeffersonhemings controversy. An intimate history by fawn brodie 1974 for its hard hitting facts. The history of a story jeffersons blood frontline pbs. The book was a commercial success, but was panned by many historians, especially jeffersonian scholars, who rejected the thesis that jefferson would procreate. Gordonreed made great advances on brodie s approach in thomas jefferson and sally hemings. Here for the first time we meet jefferson as a man of feeling and passion. The number of children he had with his black mistress sally hemings who were so. Jeffersons three daughters two free, one enslaved the. Historian fawn brodie offered a circumstantial case for the jefferson hemings affair in her jefferson. Sallys son madison hemings published in the pike county ohio republican in 1873, brodie assumes that jefferson was the father of sallys children, that he suffered from pangs of guilt throughout his life, but could not bring himself to acknowledge his relationship with a black slave either publicly or. An exceptionally rich account of jeffersons life and work.
Brodie concluded these accounts were true, a conclusion supported by a 1998 dna analysis and current scholarly consensus. The source for the birth dates of the children is jeffersons farm book. Fawn brodie ith the publication of thomas jefferson. Kazin gives a brief background of jeffersons life with regards to sally hemings and applauds, for the most part, brodie s biography.
If fawn brodie wrote hemings into the story of jeffersons life in a way that had never before been done, barbara chaseriboud, in her 1979 book, sally hemings. Apparently she was one of the first serious proponents of this relationship, and was lambasted for it, although it seems the evidence does tend to fall on her side of the fence. Chronology a popular but controversial biography 1974. The legend of legacy of fawn brodie byu scholarsarchive. Elizabeth hemings, the mother of sally, had six children by john wayles. An american controversy 1997, but she did not argue then that there was conclusive evidence linking. Brodie represents a specific, individual, material embodiment of a distinct intellectual or artistic creation found in indiana state library. In one of over thirty chapters in the book, sally hemings, brodie discusses the slave girl as one of several important passionate romantic relationships in.
What then surprised me about jeffersons relationship with sally most was the fact sally was martha jeffersons halfsister. Fawn brodie also used this information in her biography of jefferson, which contributed to her conclusion that he had fathered hemings children. History 1974, fawn brodie became the first american historian to conduct a book length study of jeffersons intimate life after martha jeffersons death in 1782. He was one of the five slaves freed in jeffersons will, all of whom were members of the hemings family. When i published my first book, thomas jefferson and sally hemings. Brodie shows jefferson as he wrestled with issues of revolution, religion, power, race, and loveambivalences that exerted a subtle but powerful influence on his political writing and his decision making. The book was a commercial success and became the toast of elite literary and social circles. Thomas jeffersons unknown grandchildren american heritage. Using complicated mathematics, probability statistics and obscure multisyllabic terms, he consistently overstates his case, making anything after the first three chapters shrill.
An intimate history revived the unprovable charge that jefferson kept a slave mistress at monticello and fathered her five children. While i may not always agree with the brodie s insights, i respect her willingness to separate opinion from fact. This controversial work was the first scholarship to assert the validity of the longrumored relationship between jefferson and sally hemings. An american controversy, in 1997, most people knew of hemings from two works. A seminal biography of thomas jefferson and an exploration of his relationship with sally hemings. When she was 14, she joined the book ofthemonth club so she could read fawn brodie s thomas jefferson. After her book was published, brodie was contacted by some eston hemings jefferson descendants who recognized his name from her account. Her bestselling psychobiography of thomas jefferson, published in 1974, was the first serious study to examine evidence related to accounts that he had taken his slave sally hemings as a concubine.
The late fawn brodie, author of the biography thomas jefferson. Professional custodians of jeffersons remains, on the other hand, may wince at brodie s elaborate reconstructions of his love affairs after his wifes death, and brodie s tabulation of how the facts have been skirted. With a novelists skill and a scholars meticulous detail, fawn m. This book is not just about thomas jefferson and sally hemings, but much, much more. Even in his farm book she remained surprisingly anonymous. Brodie produced no new evidence, her biographical account gained wide popular. Brodie certainly does have it in for that old man jefferson when she writes about the intense hatred jefferson has of patrick henry. An intimate history reignited the sally hemings rumors and introduced the world to the quackery of psychobiography using poppsychology to interpret words or actions when theres no historical evidence. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with. I read a copy of my parents book well, it was actually winthrop jordans book, the copy my parents had called white over black, and he has a chapter called thomas jeffersons self in society, and it discusses sally hemings, and i thought that that was quite interesting.
Fawn brodie, joseph smith, thomas jefferson, richard. An intimate history and barbara chaseriboud, who wrote the novel sally hemings, say categorically that jefferson had sally for his. Fawn brodie project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Fawn mckay brodie september 15, 1915 january 10, 1981 was an american biographer. Jeffersonhemings the industry practically historical. The first time i heard of sally hemings was when i was 12. I had read with great interest fawn brodies book, no man knows my history about joseph. Brodie s particular concentration was on what she described as a loving, thirtyeight.
When this scholarly book first appeared there were many who would not accept the relationship between jefferson and sally hemings. When this book was published in 1997 historians had been and were still arguing whether jefferson was the father of sally. Framing a legend goodreads meet your next favorite book. Annette gordonreed gives us a scholarly and extensive effort in her latest book, the hemings of monticello. The book itself is overwritten, though its bulk allows for a number. An intimate history, a work of psychobiography, and no man knows my history, the first prominent nonhagiographic biography of joseph smith, jr. Fawn mckay brodie september 15, 1915 january 10, 1981 was a biographer and professor of history at ucla, best known for thomas jefferson. The fact that he loved books and i loved books was something that. Sally hemings, thomas jefferson and the ways we talk about.
The necessity for secrecy concerning jeffersons liaison with sally hemings pervaded every aspect of their relationship. Regardless of the heat kicked up by the issue of thomas jefferson and sally hemings this book is about much more than that relationship. An intimate history 1974 and barbara chaseribouds novel sally. Much of the book talks about what brodie sets forth as jeffersons decadeslong relationship with sally hemings. With a novelists skill and meticulous scholarship, fawn m. Brodie into fashioning a naturalistic account of the book of mormon and joseph smiths. According to the new york times, there is a growing historical consensus among scholars that, as a widower, jefferson had a longterm relationship with hemings, and that he was the father of her six children, born after the death of his wife martha jefferson, who was the halfsister.
1440 740 1503 1043 526 1039 505 700 524 476 1239 1405 1020 1376 31 1262 1419 1013 1457 114 1200 1128 704 1071 605 1094 1363 372 113 256 258 574 875 640 1261 1512 318 330 723 1118 570 82 1132 527 849 1421 90 716 289 820 840